labour law notes completeubc law students’ society 勞動法記錄完整的ubc法律學(xué)生協(xié)會

1、Labour Law: Complete Notes: Benedet: 2010/2011 Term 1 These notes are a compilation of my class notes, my notes from the textbook, and my notes from the course package. The spelling and grammar below is atrocious, but I couldnt be bothered to fix it. Good luck! Hopefully some of this is helpful. Leg

2、al Response to Labour Issues Discrimination hard to claim, but there are legal discrimination becomes easier with clear standards and benchmarks most remedies available only to those employees who have already less Global Labour Standards could be enforced via tariffs, tax incentives non-citizens pa

3、rticularly vulnerable income inequality not directly a labour law question, but does have a labour implication ArthursThe Transformation of Work, the Disappearnce of Workers and the Future of Workplace RegulatioN 2009 from 1950s to 1970s, wokers enjoyed rising wages, more job security, greater workp

4、lace protections, and so on we have stuff like minimum wages, progressive income taxation, living wage campaigns, etc as a result of unions and social democratic parties all in the context of favorable labour market conditions, by an expanding and increasingly productive economy changes started happ

5、eing in the 1970s Changes Technology intensified the division of labour and its geographical dispersal polarized workforce by creating some knowledge workers, but consigning unskilled workers to the margin increasingly self-managed workers in knowledge sector, unskilled increasingly disciplined and

6、monitored by computers accelerating change and rapid obsolecense of woker skill Shfit from Manufacturing to service manufacturing jobs lost, moved to lower paying, less benefit jobs in the service sector with low levelf o unionization flexibilization of the workforce jobs no longer permanent, employ

7、ees will be let go ASAP where needed part=time, sort-time work used as a reserve army of labour demography increasingly heterogenous workforce, more women and visible minorities young people older than they used to be when (and if) they get jobs so more and more diverse, but perhaps solidarity more

8、challenging globalization outscouring in a global labour market emloyers have the option to move manufacturing and service jobs away from well-paid unionized workers to cheaper countries mere threat of moving has downward effect on wages. Disappearance of Workers idea of people identified as workers

9、 or working class increasingly sounds anachronistic people identify as consumer, or perhaps when experiencing unfairness as members of a disenfranchised group solidarity building exercise of workers working together under poor conditions no longer exists Shouldnt pretend some things havent gotten be

10、tter- working people are better off than they used to be, but as a qualtitative description of a group workers have disappeared as a sociological category but in a quantitative sense, there are still a great many workers and they have a lot to be mad about income inequality, inequality in livign con

11、ditions, paritcipation in politicas, educational and occupational opportunities, etc. but for whateever reason, labour movement in disarray labour issues rarely central to political debates unions increasingly unable to deliver the vote labour ministries shrinking in response workers not viewed as a

12、 constituency, but rather as a resource that must be trained, developed, and so in order to improve business The future of workplace regulation interest in creating new labour standards very low as is restructing the labour market to ensure full employmnet globalization and monetarist policies have

13、put unemployment int he hands of bankers, and neo-liberalism makes regulation anatehma collective bargainig weaked as well US failure to pass card-check even putatively pro-labour government arent adopting new labour legislation everyone focused on keepign the economy going economy dictating policy

14、to government because the average worker and the average job is changing, labour policy needs to adjust cant just focus on the male breadwinner in the vertically integrated company different kinds of workers have different kinds of needs and must be accomodated and unions sometimes view this as zero

15、-sum, accomodating one person means depriving another colective bargainign on a plant-to-plant basis makes little sense when everyone is changing jobs so ofte flexible workforce aso makes provision of benefits more complicated, and part-time workforce often not getting access to these employment ben

16、efits. manufacturing jobs no longer the norm may need some transnational law since employers can pick up and leave may need to consider who should be responsible for paying for the constant retraining necessary for a worker to adapt with the rapidly changing technology and employment how do maximum

17、hours, overtime, etc function in a Just in time world where businesses are expected to be open around the clock. Three options forget abotu labour law, and focus on human rights rather than workers rights try and work within capitalism and laissez fair afterall, under capitalism some employers reali

18、zed high-performance systems that reqarded emplowered workers and treated them well increased performance and productivity try and resusicitate the labour movement there are some new successful organizing campaigns among low-paid service workers unions and social movements may unit to try and get ga

19、ins for everyone via. living wages, work-life balance professionals, skilled technicians, athletes all have new strategies and institutions of collective action that may be exportable. this will depend to the extent that crises in capitalism will make people aware of the precariousness of their posi

20、tion, and remind them of the fallibility of capitalism so it is possible that like the street railways being revived as LRT, labour standards may reappeare in the 21st centurty, re-engineered, renamed, and ready to go as a vehicle of a revived workers movement towards the goal of social justice in t

21、he workplace. Fudge, The New Workplace: Surveying the Landscape2009 looks at changes over time of the labour market 1950s: Standard Employment Relationship served as the basis of an historical compromise between workers, employers, and governments follow ww2 aimed at protecting employees from econom

22、ic/social risk, reduce social inequality, increase economic efficiencies highly regulated by laws and collective bargaining via union members typically male, semi-skilled worker in a large industrial corporation men supported women, women looked after children few vicisble minoirties in early 1970s

23、public sector bargaining begins, real wages continued to rise and led to a rising Canadian union density also, more and more women entered the labour force 1980s: the Feminization of Labour in 1980s productivity decreased and unemloyment and inflation grew union membership peaked at 40 precent women

24、 continued to enter the labour force in order to keep household livign standards stable in the face of falling male wages women pressed for workplace rights, including protections from harrassment, job protection, pregnancy benefits, pay equity meanwhile, labour market outcomes polarizing profoundly

25、, and the old norm collapsing Risk and Reward in the New Economy Globalization and Neo-Liberalism undercut the nationstate and the goals and means for labour protections IMF and WTO blame labour market rgidiites for unemployment and poor performance aim at decentrializing bargaining new focus on emp

26、loying every adult, male or female workfare more just-in-tiem requires more workplace flexibility small business profliefarte, which meant fewer Fordist integreated procution enterprises NAFTA led to ocntinental integration benefits in Canada began to mirror the US, and our economic and welfare poli

27、cies converged tax cuts, expenditure cuts Creating a Flexible Labour Market in Canada Canada underwent a dramatic restructuring as a result of free trade and new logistic system maunfacturing rapidly shrank, as did union denisty very low in consumer services and financial and business services, much

28、 higher in public services women slightly mor elikley to be unionized as a result of more likely to be teachers, nurses, etc Young workers very rarely unionized high levels of education increasingly required for all work more people working for smaller companies, who pay less, prvide fewer benefits

29、and job security, and union representation less common more and more part-time, precarious work especially for women and new immigrants, visible minorities rarely room for promotion while fewer jobs fit the standard model, they still make up 63% of jobs proportion of good and bad jobs have been cons

30、tant but quality of new jobs questionable more likely to be temporary, ununoized, without a retirement plan growth in real wages stagnant male median income falling, while female median rising (thogh should regress ot the mean) so polarization of income some winners, some losers this rising tide is

31、not lifting all boats labour supply also more heterogenous than ever, but visible minorities tend to be concetrated in metropolitan centers paid less, less job security, more liekly ot be employed women of colour more likely to do manual labour visible minorities more likely to be low paid, face dis

32、crimination aboriginal and disabled people also face hardship, poor employment outcomes higher unemployment rates, lower education attainments but they are fertile and will make upa larger and larger part of the population, some recent improvements in western Canada possibly as a result of tighter l

33、abour markets and improvement in education levels disabled people as often unemployed most could be employed, but tend to be clustered in non-standard jobs biggest change participatin of woemn majority of women, even those with children, are working married with children often working part-time incr

34、easing hours, particularly for men, has lengthened the standard work week and contributed to work-life conflict the lengthening hourse, deterioation in wages puts household under pressure women with children, young families, particularly vulnerale need to work, but hard to support children on tose e

35、arnings divorces on the rise, as are lone-parent ffamilies Young people have to work harder and longer to make decent money leading to lower fertility old people forming a greater part of the popluation, and are working longer and longer New Labour Law Norms for the New Economy? union represtnation

36、declining little apetite to modify collective bargain legislation to make unionization easier public services used to enforce labour stnadards and human rights also collapsing the new economy is creating winners and losers, and most of those losers are traditionally disadvantaged gruops (particularl

37、y visible minorities) Risign tide of economic prosperity has not lifted all bots dspite decent growth, low unemployment and and all-time high employment rate, jobs are increasingly insecure, and the standarad employment relationship is deteriorating need to retarget employment and labour law at the

38、people who need it in the new labour market should provide equal access for men and women, support lieflong learing, and accomodates diversity Arthur/Fudge: Fordist Model Ford believed in paying his employees well, since they were also his customers wanted a population where people had disposable in

39、come Utopic? women had few rights, as did minorities women vulnerable to divorce, death of spouse, etc womens movement rises in response and women move into the econom as wages staganted, the idea that a single income could support a family became outdated. did the move of women into the workforce c

40、ause this recession? Introduction to the Common Law Contract of Employment Common law contract of employment is a normal contract between two parties, offer and agreement exchanging capital for labour in theory, terms of employment can be negotiated, but in reality this rarely occurs the normal situ

41、ation is the employer sets the terms and the employee can take it or leave it indeed, often the employee doeasnt find out the terms of employment until after theyve been hired in specialized, highly skilled field this is less common and employees may play a role in setting the bargain employment sta

42、ndards statutes putlimitations on the freedom to draft employment contracts so the freedom to contract is subject to statutory limitations for example in common law you could refuse to hire someone because of their race cannot force someone into entering a contract HRA allows a remedy here by compla

43、int to tribunal Brian A., Langille & Guy Davidov, Beyond Employees and Independent Contractors: A View from Canada Being defined as an employee or independent contractor elads to a different package of rights ie. notice only applies to employees. Statutory definitnios not helpful, often circular or

44、vaucous. new categories like Dependent contractor attempt to fill the gap, but the distinction remains. Whether someone is to be defined as contractor or employee depends on context; it is possible to be a contractor for employment purposes but an employee for vicarious liability. For labour, basic

45、distinction is that employees are in need of protection and have a particular employer, while contractors are in a position to protect themselves. Fourfold Test Basically the traditional test Control ownership of tools chance of profit risk Boils down to whether worker is controlled by employer, and

46、 whether worker is economically independent from employer ownership of tools simply evidence of these things Control means more that direct control power to discipline indicia of control, so is power to promote. Fundamentally, the distiction is between control and economic dependence.This is reflect

47、ed in the other traditional test, the business organization test which came from denning. where employee fullyt integgrated into business, contractors work is only accessory to business. Must keep eye on the goal: making sure those with an identifiable employer that need the common law protections a

48、re given themNew Problems new categories of workers that fit uneasily into traditional employee/contractor dichotomy. contractors who are not in a relationship with a single identifiable meployer, but are ieconomically dependent due to their weak market stance ie. freelance reporters, etc. New Econo

49、my and the Organization of Work proliferation of part time, causal, temporary employees subocontracting and outsourcing common in order to improve efficienices and reduce risks, cutting labour costs. Workers becoming involuntarily self-employed. When workers are economically dependent on an employer

50、, even if they are not formally employees they should be protected rather than left alone in the free market. Establishing the Employment Relationship Since employment is fundamentally treated as a contract, courts were often reluctant to force people into them this lead to racism, etc. legislature

51、eventually intervened. Seneca College of Applied Arts and Technology v. Bhadauria, 1981 2. S.C.R. 181 Issue: whether the SCC should affirm ONCAs decision to recognize a new tort of breaching the Human Rights Code. Facts: P is highly educated imigrant, well qualified. ANswered ads placed by the colle

52、ge. Never given an interview nor told why she was rejected Successful candidates were less qualified, but not imigrants. Claiming discrimination and breach of the HRC ONCA willing to recognize an idependent tort of discrimination Analysis: typically there is no such tort as refusing to consider a co

53、ntract. you cant create a new tort out of a statutory obligation, especially because the HRC itself contemplates a remedy. P should have used the remedies in the HRC to address her problem Ratio: No such tort as employment discrimination. sidenote In a Case called Cognos, the SCC held that you can b

54、ring a tort if you are hired under false pretenses P was hired from old job under apprehension it would be amazing new job turns out to suck, but employer wants to hold him to ocntract SCC says you cant do this- perhaps something akin to misrepresentation? a tort of wrongful hiring in any case. Righ

55、ts under the Contract of Employment mostly limited to termination during the employment you are bound by the terms of contract, subject to tstatutory protections but common law says you cannot be terminated without just cause, or without due notice no right to keep job if the employer gives sufficie

56、nt notice, you can be fired for any reason or payment in lieu of notice Wrongful Dismissal most disputed area Dismissal is wrongful where: the employer dismiesses without cause and without notice constructive dismissal the employee quits in repsonse to repudiatory breach of the employment contract e

57、mployer dismisses without notice, alledging but failing to prove cause. employee dismissed in breach of a statutory duty or in breahc of producedural fairness if the employment relationship is a statutory one in which the principles of administrative law apply. EXCEPTION where you are employed in a

58、federally regulated undertaking and governed by the Canada Labour code eg. banking, airlines, communications there is a special labour regime through which these employees can go to an administrative deicision maker who has the power to reinstate you into your position Reasonable Notice of Terminati

59、on Sometimes the employment contract sets out notice period or payment in lieu of, but courts may not enforce if no express provision, they will look at intent of parties, include past practice and policy statements in HR documents, etc. But for whatever reason, in Canada the courts have usually jus

60、t decided what is reasonable in the circumstances, disregarding hte parites intentions. Employment Standards act sets out minimum notice standards typically quite low, and the common law often will give more so if you are terminated without notice, you can sue for wrongful dismissal but you can reco