L.7_Policy Analysis_Framework_2015 1216課件

1、MSW-2015Public Policy & Social Work in ChinaLecture 7:Analytical Framework II:The Gilbert & Specht Model (Dr. LI Ping-wai)Email: .hkPublic Policy as Choice:What benefits are to be offered to whom?How these benefits are to be delivered?How they are to be financed?Four major dimensions of Choice of th

2、is framework:What are the bases of social allocations?What are the types of social provisions to be allocated?What are the strategies for the delivery of these provisions?What are the methods of financing these provisions?Three axes of analysis:The range of alternatives within each dimension?The soc

3、ial values that lend support to these alternatives?The theories or assumptions implicit in these alternatives?Allocation & ProvisionsThe first two dimensions of choice are expressed in the questions:Who gets what? (The bases of social allocation addresses the UN of public welfare policy)Allocation &

4、 Provisions:The bases of social allocations refers to the choice among:various principle upon which social provisions are made accessible to people and groups in society. Allocation & Provisions:The question about the nature of social provisions refer to:the form in which benefits are delivered.Deli

5、very & Finance:The last two dimensions of choice are expressed in the question:arrangements must be made for getting the selected social provisions to the eligible consumers.delivery strategies refer to: alternative organizational arrangements among distributors and consumers of benefits.Delivery &

6、Finance:Financing choices involve the various sources:the form of cash the funding places to the service providersSummary of the framework:To view public policy as a benefit allocation mechanism, the design of which requires that 4 types of choices must be made.To seek a clear and precise understand

7、-ing of the basic alternatives within each of these 4 dimensions of choice.Summary of the framework:3.To obtain insights into why any one of these alternative policy choices may be preferred over others by explicating the values, theories, and assumptions implicit in the policy design.Values Preference & Social Choice:The relationship of the 4 dimensions of choice with the continum of values between individualism and collectivism asfollows: Dimensions of Choices & Competing Value Orientation:Individualist Dimensions Collectivistcost effectiveness allocation social effec