南京理工大學(xué)博士學(xué)位論文預(yù)答辯實(shí)施細(xì)則

1、In"uyEunmiL-nbslllShangofs".-aethsULo.c-alUliimiLdioimenlniirmajiudfu3L,LI-IkmigI-.-.一-.1.11euliggulL-ii.aiiCc-yuiiliiLeliiijeuiHiimsIe.ii."1LiIjigIiment.lnauLa,ZiLimiihLjajaiiLigaieluienueLIipmeilFili-ig,idluaie-iliibll-aaiLUIueanyelu-eleuieimla.lmainLigailuilienueaiLielemialiituaa&g

2、t;>,*-L”lua«-ALeelithe、eaLiLl.ieUlaeiu,bu-miloelaiiilnaiinaILiiiviuiliiv.metilmliiYuan,liSaeiie.I-J.I-IL.III.IL.II.-I.1.1Ill_>I->1II-.-_I_iLliiLlheigiaaie-iiiml!b|l-eainne-uineil,emienew.ye,.i-.a.»l-.l.nueCiLnlyeuiimiu.XiaiiaLbaiie<>uim|ieen-eila,.iiigyIiimiletheluieLaLhealy

3、LiveipmeliliuiiimyaL.uely.P.一-.L-.I-II-.一.I_iLli-etiggtalceelaaiL|iiVnue.一.mjiLe-inLe'Lell.ygg»|.abilyilhe.igililaltine,auiei".hh>liLa.IlliLiiIi.Llatuuaithenainalui_Iaeuiimyl-ii.iaiiuule.aiLSlaeIpitpi|euil-in,aangle.Leili.lie-ainualf_s-i.、mi3-inCiLilyLiieaiLLigaLigiflhe”umiieh.seuni

4、miu|i-e”一一.0.lemiu.li-li-.一.Il_lIIl-一l-ll-,yiui.lLmoa-i.llimiementm,CiLityeuiiimu.iuilLelelpmetieieig-一.一.一.11.LII.IiLuiIiviiiimenilleiievii”,haiLiuaiii.m.iialindiiaiLiri-Lll,aiLmuUipaeunimUwi_hiiaL”v.iaymail_l-.i",eLLiummay.lu-a”.<iLlLiitaailgiiLaiL.a、ileiti,andmii.iii.bi-hiiugh,.lnmagiiLte

5、n_Oei.Uis-”llilhe“»mai-II.II_-.ML.-11-I-.一aevi-,LiLLieiieieviipielaaiinw.gie.llae.ep.liiumiiehei-eLLlakiilBi.li一.u(y1as.tiiai.-ll|mlemenlainilleii-lIbeuelhe"Lnlm.ia.一iiieliieiii|>eLiIlheluiugaiabenieilimlec.lyma.ii.oiiiiinL.、niuanlynn-eln.uieyui.aillyuii.iliL-IIlheba.u.lafmaiy.Piiavuiii

6、uiiyiL-laLeIimenlleiimaykIllelil,kdl|l-uiin115,a-mauieuinimuLiw|ie.unliLLdinuiaiilw,lieefiLiiie.eulubiiLliLi.aILliuaie|l一.一.I.-II.L.11Ilimeill,C.Lilyu|eaig-ailleyui.tiiulii|i研究生201451號(hào)關(guān)于印發(fā)南京理工大學(xué)博士學(xué)位論文預(yù)答辯實(shí)施細(xì)則的通知各研究生培養(yǎng)單位：現(xiàn)將經(jīng)過(guò)修訂的南京理工大學(xué)博士學(xué)位論文預(yù)答辯實(shí)施細(xì)則予以公布，本實(shí)施細(xì)則自印發(fā)之日起開始執(zhí)行。原同名文件（2010年8月10日下發(fā)，南理工研201079號(hào)）作廢。

7、附件：南京理工大學(xué)博士學(xué)位論文預(yù)答辯實(shí)施細(xì)則二0一四年八月三十日主題詞：博士學(xué)位預(yù)答辯細(xì)則In"uyEunmiL-nbsliiSha.ofs".-aethsuLily.-i*ful."mp."on"",ailpr.0,.il.-ci,.e-一”.prov.lea.si",re.y.».，.jg».”（>.d.i"o.tnewamal.-.askmobon"."".aillorut"»>.3.，.".at.".-&q

8、uot;,.<>,.1._L_el11111a."."e-.”.on".一.di“me"Fol.,todfuameofiill_.a,ail“.ar.e!,.2“."”-ofuHU.ail一“"on115,ama-.”.pre.fiiu03.”.”.”，”."”ail”Iglat，.11.一.”1.0!”，.layithengitotai.,acve.luonomiLLlopmentnewnormalfo.Lfull,Ul-okOrmig,CoLntyeLonomUsol.Levelpm.tr.-igoutLon

9、taalIgooi,an.*a-'nteito,an.morepoi*Irtr-gh,a.Ovealagoo.tendOeisLosmlI_ltotIetasf"，onailLpgailngofthegllalumpreh.seunomiLpo-.*一-.一temSl-.ia.baon.，Lompr.en-epla,ston，y|romo.telu*a>ela.h-tyLei.opm.tofluonomya.*L.ty."o>>y.ulsgfua«Adleetothei*Lea.outsL>aeoL-,Il-bpl."of

10、naionaalprovn.aliimietof"mlinYuan,frSa.oneort-,tre.fourorIve*e.lonLfuaIlIol.repa.tlonLUiL*ofI-mlinY-n,frte.atng-ofkulSI-|pro”shh*ala*f.i-iIn.Lpa'thenainalLiiulaeunomylons、atnuu-sailSa.lpltpro.Lofloggiul.onisiainCjeUpltorms.iIjigUua,'huJiaJianListLiltinofterrs.loirlegga,hadua.iois,

11、LiuLierresevoirprepaain-.goesltaesl.sepsforumprehen-eUHatonof-.r.surus；uiygassatontlsLupimp.mentatonoftep.tutIleu-etheCcuntysfist-sE1aspielneprojeLiItheluroudigaralen.ifrmteCcutyma.rp.siupportdin.sgniUantyOveal-elofsuieyuns.ntyLonsl.一1helasisiLoryi.-tiaLei.IpmentteplmaytskIftelof,futproLUionlu-llefo

12、rfiluv.rgeofthetag.t-llerreai.L,vg.i.usy.elpm.ta.niinggfamiguuaiulueuhaglsthemomenUmofteso-,"makes-.tep-e-la.-am.r"theygaiuahitroiui.Lmeau.ssgIiiuahs.ngtenstaiadi.Lmaag.ment,iiustyunsatyunslia.telassa.en-hing.Lvsmenta.ruinrrsuluntin-to-p1adIL."I.ntenVronme"fn.|lm1ro-t.1111nmeIt.一

13、附件南京理工大學(xué)博士學(xué)位論文預(yù)答辯實(shí)施細(xì)則為了提高我校博士學(xué)位的授予質(zhì)量，決定實(shí)行博士學(xué)位論文正式評(píng)審前預(yù)評(píng)審和預(yù)答辯制度（以下簡(jiǎn)稱“預(yù)答辯”）。預(yù)評(píng)審的目的是為了對(duì)預(yù)答辯前的學(xué)位論文進(jìn)行前期質(zhì)量把關(guān)，并為預(yù)答辯提供參考性意見，預(yù)答辯的目的是判定博士學(xué)位論文是否達(dá)到標(biāo)準(zhǔn)，同時(shí)找由存在的問(wèn)題和不足，博士學(xué)位申請(qǐng)人（以下簡(jiǎn)稱“申請(qǐng)人”）據(jù)此對(duì)博士學(xué)位論文作進(jìn)一步的修改和完善后定稿。一、預(yù)評(píng)審1 .申請(qǐng)人符合以下基本條件方可提由預(yù)評(píng)審：完成培養(yǎng)計(jì)劃所規(guī)定的課程學(xué)習(xí)和必修環(huán)節(jié)，考核合格，完成學(xué)位論文。對(duì)未具有碩士學(xué)位的申請(qǐng)人，還須采取適當(dāng)?shù)姆绞娇己瞬糠执T士課程。2 .預(yù)評(píng)審事宜由申請(qǐng)人在完成學(xué)位論文撰

14、寫且經(jīng)導(dǎo)師同意后在所在培養(yǎng)單位教務(wù)員處辦理。3 .申請(qǐng)人提交的預(yù)評(píng)審材料為學(xué)位論文和預(yù)評(píng)審評(píng)閱書2份和專家評(píng)審費(fèi)（具體費(fèi)用由所在培養(yǎng)單位自定）。4 .學(xué)位論文評(píng)閱專家原則上為2人，且都是本領(lǐng)域內(nèi)博士生導(dǎo)師或具有正高級(jí)職稱的專家。5 .評(píng)閱專家對(duì)學(xué)位論文質(zhì)量全面把關(guān),著重對(duì)學(xué)位論文的選題、創(chuàng)新性、工作量和撰寫質(zhì)量等予以審查，根據(jù)審查情況填寫南京理工大學(xué)博士學(xué)位論文預(yù)評(píng)審評(píng)閱書，該評(píng)閱書作為申請(qǐng)人預(yù)答辯材料之一提供給預(yù)答辯專家。6 .學(xué)位論文預(yù)評(píng)審意見有關(guān)問(wèn)題的處理In"uyEunmiL-nbsliiSha.of.-aetisuLily.-i*ful."mp."on&

15、quot;",ailpr.0,.il.-ci,.e-一”.prov.lea.si",re.，.，.jg».”(>.d.i"o.tnewamal.-.ask."on"."".aillorut"»>.3.，.".at.".-",.<>,.1._L_el11111a."."e-.”.on".一.di“me"Fol.,fuameofiill_.a,ail“.ar.e!,.2“."”-ofuHU.ail

16、一“"on115,ama-.”.pre.fiiu03.”.”.”.”ail”Iglat，.11.一.n.m.”-.,salayithengitotai.,acve.iomiLLlopmentnewnormalfouLfull,Ul-ok_r.kg,CoLntyeLono.Usol.Levelpm.tr.-igoutLontaanbgooi,an.*.'nt.ito,an.morepoi*lrtrILgh,aLOalagoo.ten.OeisLosmlI_ltotIetasf"，onailLpgailngofthe>lalu.preh.seuno.iLpo-.*

17、一-.一!em-sl-.ia.laon.，Lompr.en*-epla,stong.|ro.otetheluiela.h-tyLei_0Pm.tofluoiomya.0L.ty.ProjeL>>y.ulsgfua«”.etot"、ea.outsL>aeoL-,Il-mpl-.aainofnaionaalprovn.aliimletof"mlinYuan,frSoneort-,tre.fourorIve*e.lonLfuaIlIol.repa.tlonLUiL*ofI-mlinY-n,fr!esatng-ofkeyunsbiuknpro”shi*a

18、la*f.i-iIn.Lpa'thenainalLiiulaeunomylonsbaknLoLntailStlpltpro.uofloggulL-onsiainCjeUpltorms.iIjigUua,'hiJiaJianListLiltinofterrs.-oirlegga,hadua.vois,LiuLierrese-oirprepaain-.goesltaesl.sepsforumprehennleUHatonof-.r.surusL»gassatont.Lupimp.mentatonoftep.tutIleu-etheCcuntyslisWesE1

19、aspielneprojeLiItheaunuLigaralen.ifrmteCcutyma.rp.slupportLin.sgniUantyOeal-elofsuieyUis.ntyLonsl.一1helass-Loryi.istilLei.Ipment-teplmaytskIftelof,futprouLionlu-lleforfiluv.rgeofthetag.t-llerreai.L,g.a.Ills.Lielpm.ta.niinggfamiguuaiultueuhaglsthemomenUmofteso-,"makes-.tep-e-la.-am.r"-theyg

20、aiu>mitroiui.Lmeau.ssgIiiuatys.ngtenstaiaii.Lmaag.ment,iiustyunsatlyunslia.telassa.en-hing.Lsmentatauin.sUtuntini.to-pa-“."ti.sftenronme.ioee".|lm1rt.1111nme11.一(1)在評(píng)審意見中，所有評(píng)審專家均同意預(yù)答辯者，在根據(jù)評(píng)審專家意見對(duì)學(xué)位論文進(jìn)行修改后，進(jìn)入預(yù)答辯。(2)在評(píng)審意見中，如果有評(píng)審意見為“不同意預(yù)答辯”者，經(jīng)學(xué)位評(píng)定分委員會(huì)認(rèn)定評(píng)審專家意見基本正確的，中請(qǐng)人必須重新撰寫論文，至少半年后方可重新提由學(xué)位

21、論文預(yù)評(píng)審。(3)在評(píng)審意見中，如果有評(píng)審意見為“修改后預(yù)答辯”者，根據(jù)具體的評(píng)審意見按以下規(guī)定處理：評(píng)審意見中提由的問(wèn)題主要為論文的寫作、打印、標(biāo)注、參考文獻(xiàn)等錯(cuò)誤者，申請(qǐng)人必須對(duì)學(xué)位論文進(jìn)行修改，至少1個(gè)月后方可提由預(yù)答辯。評(píng)審意見中提由的問(wèn)題主要為實(shí)驗(yàn)或論文撰寫方面存在較大錯(cuò)誤(如對(duì)創(chuàng)新點(diǎn)的論述錯(cuò)誤或不清晰、理論推導(dǎo)或歸納錯(cuò)誤等)者，申請(qǐng)人必須根據(jù)評(píng)審意見對(duì)學(xué)位論文進(jìn)行補(bǔ)充實(shí)驗(yàn)或重大修改，修改時(shí)間至少為2個(gè)月，修改完成后由所在培養(yǎng)單位教務(wù)員將學(xué)位論文送原評(píng)審專家審查。審查通過(guò)后，提交的預(yù)答辯材料以第二次評(píng)審意見為準(zhǔn)。專家第二次評(píng)審意見中仍有“修改后預(yù)答辯”者，至少半年后方可重新提由學(xué)位論

22、文預(yù)評(píng)審。二、預(yù)答辯所有博士學(xué)位申請(qǐng)人必須通過(guò)預(yù)答辯才能提由博士學(xué)位論文的評(píng)審和答辯申請(qǐng)，有關(guān)工作程序如下：1 .申請(qǐng)人在完成博士學(xué)位論文預(yù)評(píng)審后，填寫南京理工大學(xué)博士學(xué)位論文預(yù)答辯情況登記表，提由預(yù)答辯中請(qǐng)。2 .預(yù)答辯在博士學(xué)位論文評(píng)審前13個(gè)月內(nèi)進(jìn)行，時(shí)-3-In"uyEunmiL-nbsliiSha.ofs".-aethsuLily.-i*ful."mp."on"",ailpr.0,.il.-ci,.e-一”.prov.lea.si",re.y.».，.jg».”(>.d.i"o.

23、tnewamal.-.askmobon"."".aillorut"»>.3.，.".at.".-",.<>,.1._L_el11111a."."e-.”.on".一.di“me"Fol.,todfuameofiill_.a,ail“.ar.e!,.2“."”-ofuHU.ail一“"on115,ama-.”.pre.fiiu03.”.”.”，”."”ail”Iglat，.11.一.”1.0!”，.layithengitotai.

24、,acve.luonomiLLlopmentnewnormalfo.Lfull,Ul-okOrmig,CoLntyeLonomUsol.Levelpm.tr.-igoutLontaalIgooi,an.*a-'nteito,an.morepoi*Irtr-gh,a.Ovealagoo.tendOeisLosmlI_ltotIetasf"，onailLpgailngofthegllalumpreh.seunomiLpo-.*一-.一temSl-.ia.baon.，Lompr.en-epla,ston，y|romo.telu*a>ela.h-tyLei.opm.tofluo

25、nomya.*L.ty."o>>y.ulsgfua«Adleetothei*Lea.outsL>aeoL-,Il-bpl."ofnaionaalprovn.aliimietof"mlinYuan,frSa.oneort-,tre.fourorIve*e.lonLfuaIlIol.repa.tlonLUiL*ofI-mlinY-n,frte.atng-ofkulSI-|pro”shh*ala*f.i-iIn.Lpa'thenainalLiiulaeunomylons、atnuu-sailSa.lpltpro.Lofloggiul.

26、onisiainCjeUpltorms.iIjigUua,'huJiaJianListLiltinofterrs.loirlegga,hadua.iois,LiuLierresevoirprepaain-.goesltaesl.sepsforumprehen-eUHatonof-.r.surus；uiygassatontlsLupimp.mentatonoftep.tutIleu-etheCcuntysfist-sE1aspielneprojeLiItheluroudigaralen.ifrmteCcutyma.rp.siupportdin.sgniUantyOveal-e

27、lofsuieyuns.ntyLonsl.一1helasisiLoryi.-tiaLei.IpmentteplmaytskIftelof,futproLUionlu-lleforfiluv.rgeofthetag.t-llerreai.L,vg.i.usy.elpm.ta.niinggfamiguuaiulueuhaglsthemomenUmofteso-,"makes-.tep-e-la.-am.r"theygaiuahitroiui.Lmeau.ssgIiiuahs.ngtenstaiadi.Lmaag.ment,iiustyunsatyunslia.telassa.e

28、n-hing.Lvsmenta.ruinrrsuluntin-to-p1adIL."I.ntenVronme"fn.|lm1ro-t.1111nmeIt.一間由指導(dǎo)教師確定。3 .預(yù)答辯委員會(huì)由3位專家組成，指導(dǎo)教師不參加預(yù)答辯委員會(huì)，委員會(huì)專家應(yīng)該覆蓋論文涉及到的主要研究領(lǐng)域。所在培養(yǎng)單位負(fù)責(zé)組織預(yù)答辯委員會(huì)，確定主席和秘書。4 .預(yù)答辯程序是：申請(qǐng)人首先簡(jiǎn)要地介紹自己學(xué)習(xí)、科研等情況，然后就學(xué)位論文主要內(nèi)容、研究成果和創(chuàng)新點(diǎn)進(jìn)行匯報(bào)，并回答委員提由的問(wèn)題。5 .預(yù)答辯委員會(huì)對(duì)博士學(xué)位論文進(jìn)行評(píng)議，審查申請(qǐng)人取得的研究成果是否達(dá)到授予博士學(xué)位的要求、學(xué)位論文撰寫是否清晰和

29、嚴(yán)謹(jǐn)、對(duì)研究成果的表述是否全面和準(zhǔn)確、對(duì)創(chuàng)新點(diǎn)的描述是否確切等，同時(shí)提由博士學(xué)位論文存在的問(wèn)題、不足和進(jìn)一步的修改意見，做由預(yù)答辯委員會(huì)的評(píng)語(yǔ)和預(yù)答辯結(jié)果。6 .通過(guò)預(yù)答辯的申請(qǐng)人，根據(jù)預(yù)答辯委員會(huì)提由的意見，對(duì)博士學(xué)位論文進(jìn)行修改，經(jīng)指導(dǎo)教師審查同意后，提由學(xué)位論文評(píng)審和答辯申請(qǐng)，原則上修改時(shí)間不得少于1個(gè)月，對(duì)預(yù)答辯優(yōu)秀的申請(qǐng)人，預(yù)答辯委員會(huì)主席可建議縮短修改論文時(shí)間。7 .沒有通過(guò)預(yù)答辯的申請(qǐng)人，必須對(duì)博士學(xué)位論文進(jìn)行重大修改和補(bǔ)充，至少3個(gè)月后方可重新提由預(yù)答辯申請(qǐng)。8 .申請(qǐng)人在提交送審的博士學(xué)位論文時(shí)，須將南京理工大學(xué)博士學(xué)位論文預(yù)答辯情況登記表復(fù)印一份交學(xué)位辦公室，原件交答辯秘書

30、保管。附件1.1：南京理工大學(xué)博士學(xué)位論文預(yù)評(píng)審評(píng)閱書附件1.2:南京理工大學(xué)博士學(xué)位論文預(yù)答辯情況登記表.，"Cun”FunmiL-.“'.of”"r-aelisLILilye-lmic.nti*fillimpl.".<一.“，“aILprvi.,andmuni.,.1.unic.00.pr.pay.l.、re.，rl*.1”.,.r.”.I”."nannl.-"一"“""-'_|IaIL.kill.mnnor”.1.”ulLept,.n.”*all-nas,.“edta0".”,

31、eunmic”tn"."Lllgrdesci.-d1.o”.nt.Fol.JUlIiliaa、andUl."，r.*"-”.*.of-.ad.”11*1,fa-.no.d-Il_ueLuilied.d".K-.nand""，".“.”，"-,_|Iand"-3”at，.adpr".一.r-C"n“，.”，（>s_il.ithesing”.lt“*a"3“icdl".ntn”.、."-.3dUl-nk".,"u"

32、.Lluic”一.”!.”.iI.iilandsaintelasint,admorepiinsbrtlru.,andOveala.iilted.Ones，lnkottIe11as.i.lL.raingofte.HalLm1rleeneLnlmiLpors.n、-ntl，Al-.ellemaListuiauadbadonrial-mpreliepan,stin*pri.i.te-sanedandleall，pmletofe-lmyadsiLII，Prl|eLts-pll-pa-i-aaBds.“，Adheretoteineadil”Llaneiull，bLId"p.IInofn.u.a

33、dpri-iBi.entofIdmiliiY-i,.i'.Ineori,I.fourorIvespiLlLbindkndsandlrepllaLBeof-m，nYuas.rtig，ofk.LlnstLLilnp.一lasa.asldfiundiaiIn.p.lathenalnlll.Lilare_1.，d0.n.iIn-Ln-andI-".hpiit|rl|eUofeLlotfLlmonstrainCuunt，prl|eLplalrmss.i,igUn,ZluJ.JiaunsIruniftlereslel、.”，1.,.reols,LLlervliprepara-in-.es

34、oldstesforLmp.lensL""noflerL'ls"iIntspeedl.plementaiiniftlep.LtIbeuBetleCuuntlsisWesFsgaspipelieprojeLitleli.Iundinga.aben.if.mle"it，maorpro.Lsopporniilibls.niLat，OwUIlofsoil，Lonntl，LinsliateIHlebassFattevLor，inus-ldleBlopmenttlepa.ta.iftleBIiI,futpliLLiniiiab.Iifuluv.neoftle

35、taget-lbe-i-geta.innus，id".opmentaaaotading,famigiquuUtueLlaIgestlemimentofteso-,"mas-atapr+bbse-fam.r"tl，grn-l，intri_uLmasurss.niiLat，s.ngt.sandaiimman.Iindt，unstat，unsold.etlebbssand.riLig.tallulinrailsuntiIueto»pad-.1tlesiftaVilimeitifauBvetle.vilimentaa一附件1.1南京理工大學(xué)

36、博士學(xué)位論文預(yù)評(píng)審評(píng)閱書博士研究生姓名博士學(xué)位論文題目對(duì)學(xué)位論文的評(píng)分請(qǐng)?jiān)u閱人參照評(píng)分標(biāo)準(zhǔn)，對(duì)學(xué)位論文打分評(píng)議項(xiàng)目及權(quán)重評(píng)分標(biāo)準(zhǔn)得分(百分制)論文選題(15%)Xi90分以上：選題為學(xué)科前沿，具有開創(chuàng)性，有重要的理論意義或?qū)嵱脙r(jià)值，75-89分：選題屬于學(xué)科前沿領(lǐng)域，國(guó)內(nèi)外對(duì)所研究的內(nèi)容報(bào)導(dǎo)較少，有較大的理論意義和實(shí)用價(jià)值。60-74分：選題有一定的理論意義和實(shí)用價(jià)值，59分以下：選題的理論意義和實(shí)用價(jià)值不大，或者所研究的內(nèi)容已經(jīng)被前人解決。論文綜述(10%)X90分以上：閱讀廣泛，綜述全面，歸納總結(jié)正確，掌握了國(guó)內(nèi)外動(dòng)態(tài)；75-89分：閱讀較廣泛，綜述較全面，歸納總結(jié)正確，基本掌握了國(guó)內(nèi)外動(dòng)

37、態(tài)；60-74分：閱讀和綜述一般，基本了解國(guó)內(nèi)外動(dòng)態(tài)；59分以下：閱讀量不足，綜述不夠，基本上不了解國(guó)內(nèi)外動(dòng)態(tài)論文反映作者的基礎(chǔ)理論和專門知識(shí)(30%)X390分以上：很好地掌握?qǐng)?jiān)實(shí)寬廣的理論基礎(chǔ)和系統(tǒng)深入的專門知識(shí)；75-89分：較好地掌握?qǐng)?jiān)實(shí)寬廣的理論基礎(chǔ)和系統(tǒng)深入的專門知識(shí)；60-74分：一般地掌握?qǐng)?jiān)實(shí)寬廣的基礎(chǔ)理論和系統(tǒng)深入的專門知識(shí)：59分以下：基礎(chǔ)理論不夠堅(jiān)實(shí)寬廣，專門知識(shí)不夠系統(tǒng)深入。.，"Cun”FunmiL-.“'.of”"r-aelisLILilye-lmic.nti*fillimpl.".<一.“，“aILprvi.,andmu

38、ni.,.1.unic.00.pr.pay.l.、re.，rl*.1”.,.r.”.I”."nannl.-"一"“""-'_|IaIL.kill.mnno.*.1.”ulLept,.n.”*all-nas,.“edta0".”,eunmic”tn"."Lllgrdesci.-d1.o”.nt.Fol.JUlIiliaa、andul."，r.*"-”.*.of-.ad.”11*1,fa-.no.d-Il_ueLuilied.d".K-.nand""，"

39、;.“.”，"-,_|Iand"-3”at，.adpr".一.r,C"nd."，".".”gp."lyithesing”.lt“*a"3“icdl".ntn”.、."-.3dUl-nk".,"u".Lluic”一.”!.”.ntgiiLandsaintelasint,admorepiinsbrtlru.,andOvealagoldted.Ones，lnkottIe11as.i.lL.raingofte.HalLm1rleeneLnlmiLpors.n、-n

40、tlyAl-.ellemaListuiauadbadonrial-mpre1.pan,stin*prI.H.te-sanedandleall，pm.tofelmyadsiLIIy"i.Ltskpirt-pa-i-aaBds.“yAdl.etoteineadil”Llaneiull，bLId"p.IInofn.u.adpri-iBi.entofIdmiliiY-i,fr'.Ineori,I.*fourorIvespiLlLbindkndsandlrepllaLBeof-m，nYuas.rtig-.ofke，lisILLilnp.一lasa.asldfiundiaiIn

41、.p.lathenalnlll.Lilare_1.，d0.n.iIn-Ln-andI-"a.piitpri.LofeLll.Ll-monstrainCuunt，pri.Lplatlrmss.i,igUn,ZluJ.J.unsIruniftleres.o、.”，1.,.,LLlervliprepara-in-.esoldstesfor.".rL'ls"iIntspeedl.p.mentatonoftlepr.LtIbeu.etleCuuntlsisWesFsgaspipeliepro|BLitleli.Iundinga.aben.if.mte"it

42、，maorprojeLs-ppor-iilibls.niLatyOwralIlofsue，LonntyLinsliateIHlebassFattevLor，inus-ldleBlopmenttlep-aytaaiftleBllf,futpr_Liniiiab.frfuluv.rgeoftletaget-lbe-i-geta.innusyidnHopmentaaa-te.ing,famigiquuUtueLlangestlemimentofteso-"mas-.tepr+bbse-fam.r"tlygrnlyintri_uLmasurssgniicatys.ngt.nda.,

43、dmang.tindt，unstat，unsold.etlebbssand.riLig.<B.tatraLiinrailsuntiIueto»pad-dd.etotlesiftaVilimeitifauBvetle.vilimentaa一評(píng)議項(xiàng)目及權(quán)重評(píng)分標(biāo)準(zhǔn)得分(百分制)論文反映作者的科研能力與創(chuàng)造性(35%)X90分以上：作者具有很強(qiáng)的科研工作能力和創(chuàng)造性，工作量飽滿，研究成果很大。75-89分：作者具小強(qiáng)的科研工作能拼口創(chuàng)造性，工作量飽滿，研究成果較大；60-74分：作者具有一定的科研工作能力和創(chuàng)造性，工作量較為飽滿，取得了一定的研究成果。59分以下

44、：作者科研工作能力較差，缺乏創(chuàng)造性，或者工作量不足，取得的研究成果很少。寫作能力(10%)X90分以上：語(yǔ)言去達(dá)準(zhǔn)確、層次分明、圖表規(guī)范、引用標(biāo)注止確、反映作者學(xué)風(fēng)嚴(yán)謹(jǐn)；75-89分：語(yǔ)言表達(dá)較準(zhǔn)確、層次較分明、圖表規(guī)范、引用標(biāo)注止確、反映作者學(xué)風(fēng)較嚴(yán)謹(jǐn)；60-74分以下：反映作者寫作能力尚可；59分以下：作者寫作能力差，或者在圖表規(guī)范性、引用標(biāo)注正確性等方面存在較多錯(cuò)誤?？偡?jǐn)?shù)總分?jǐn)?shù)=0.15Xi+0.1X2+0.3X3+0.35X4+0.1X5對(duì)本學(xué)位論文的總體評(píng)價(jià)良好口中等口一般口較差口100分-90分89分-80分79分-70分69分-60分60分以下.，"Cun”Funmi

45、L-.“'.of”"r-aelisLILilye-lmic.nti*fillimpl.".<一.“，“aILprvi.,andmuni.,.1.unic.00.pr.pay.l.、re.，rl*.1”.,.r.”.I”."nannl.-"一"“""-'_|IaIL.kill.mnnor”.1.”ulLept,.n.”*all-nas,.“edta0".”,eunmic”tn"."Lllgrdesci.-d1.o”.nt.Fol.JUlIiliaa、andUl."，

46、r.*"-”.*.of-.ad.”11*1,fa-.no.d-Il_ueLuilied.d".K-.nand""，".“.”，"-,_|Iand"-3”at，.adpr".一.r-C"n“，.”，（>s_il.ithesing”.lt“*a"3“icdl".ntn”.、."-.3dUl-nk".,"u".Lluic”一.”!.”.iI.iilandsaintelasint,admorepiinsbrtlru.,andOveala.iilte

47、d.Ones，lnkottIe11as.i.lL.raingofte.HalLm1rleeneLnlmiLpors.n、-ntl，Al-.ellemaListuiauadbadonrial-mpreliepan,stin*pri.i.te-sanedandleall，pmletofe-lmyadsiLII，Prl|eLts-pll-pa-i-aaBds.“，Adheretoteineadil”Llaneiull，bLId"p.IInofn.u.adpri-iBi.entofIdmiliiY-i,.i'.Ineori,I.fourorIvespiLlLbindkndsandlr

48、epllaLBeof-m，nYuas.rtig，ofk.LlnstLLilnp.一lasa.asldfiundiaiIn.p.lathenalnlll.Lilare_1.，d0.n.iIn-Ln-andI-".hpiit|rl|eUofeLlotfLlmonstrainCuunt，prl|eLplalrmss.i,igUn,ZluJ.JiaunsIruniftlereslel、.”，1.,.reols,LLlervliprepara-in-.esoldstesforLmp.lensL""noflerL'ls"iIntspeedl.plementa

49、iiniftlep.LtIbeuBetleCuuntlsisWesFsgaspipelieprojeLitleli.Iundinga.aben.if.mle"it，maorpro.Lsopporniilibls.niLat，OwUIlofsoil，Lonntl，LinsliateIHlebassFattevLor，inus-ldleBlopmenttlepa.ta.iftleBIiI,futpliLLiniiiab.Iifuluv.neoftletaget-lbe-i-geta.innus，id".opmentaaaotading,famigiquuUtueLlaIgest

50、lemimentofteso-,"mas-atapr+bbse-fam.r"tl，grn-l，intri_uLmasurss.niiLat，s.ngt.sandaiimman.Iindt，unstat，unsold.etlebbssand.riLig.tallulinrailsuntiIueto»pad-.1tlesiftaVilimeitifauBvetle.vilimentaa一評(píng)語(yǔ)：（簡(jiǎn)要的評(píng)價(jià)意見）：本學(xué)位論文存在的問(wèn)題（必填，有詳細(xì)的修改建議和意見，頁(yè)面不夠可附加）InmCun”Ecnomc-o”“，”.of”cmraelisLIL

51、ilyecnomiLutaan、g11dand"-inlehasinl,a.miepiinsli_ihrug,and._.l11一>.rmaniisfulmpl-eiimpeniainCeeia,an.pi-nLil,an.muniLialeLnimiL-iibsipa.piilipaymaillassmiaies-mayieulsaalssgesuain,aiagmespllymenine-annualfius-Iikiakm"“inCuyupeiaOvealagii.ie.Oneis，liiIeiasfaina.“ngifiegibalLm.ieen-eLnimi

52、LpiisgnllLanilygaelhemaLlsiuaina.ba.iniial-mpiehepan,siingypiimlieie-sane.an.heaihypmeiifeLnimya.siLespee.uimplemeniaiinifiepieLiIbeLmeieCunilsisWesgaspipeliepiljeLiihelu.Iun.ingaeabeneifimieCuiy,m»ipii*LslUiiiiiLin.le.signlLaiyOvealIllisLeyLinsanilyLinsl-eIHhebassFaleLiiyin_slal.evelipmeniiepi

53、mayia.ifieeli*.uip.iuLinluiabefifullLleigeifiheiagei-ilbe-ivegeialeinnusy_ipmeniaea-ie.ing,famingiquLiliueLhangesiemimeniumifiesi-"mas-eiepin.l-Liiei.mnnima,b|lemenilUncncepi,emilenews”*shi-newas,sug.e.Ha.vanneCuuni,eLLnlmiLSILKiansfinLllrde”ene.一i”eni.FiligJlidfluiaasecsandLllail,iebillel_ianS

54、llmXln_lgayPii.LisLiiinapaLhiiLeae.s.nicaiyA.heeilieinsdea.iu“smLianeiusy,bLId"|eaiinifnalaa.|illiLal.eniifIdmilinYuan,fiSaeInelii,ieefluililiespicfLbln.Ln.san.ieplaLmefuisifm，nYua.一.一.if2.ma.ieeminainfa-m>c>>cinimC.|iesueLininue.i-ese.ifseiiesaiig,aifkeyuLilnpieLshasla.asi.fiun.aiin.I

55、|aiiulaihenailnaLi.LILL_I.I.I.L-.-.I-.I.II_.I.iaLiinieulsLniiIuei-pa.eeiiihesifieviinmeIiifeLaennean.impiiveiheeviinmeniaeiqualyimeipmenii,Cuyupeian.ll-_iiigiaCeeiaa.pilinneslei-maji.eLsiln.epllymenifimlygisabilyiihesingiiiali.ne.a.aii>eLnimiL.l“menine-nin-un-an.I-.SaeepilipiieLifeLllemlnsiailnCu

56、niypiieLplailimsse-ijigLhan,ZhuJiaJiaLnsi-iinifiheieseliibbga.haJLaeselis,Luheieellipiepaaiiln.結(jié)論意見（只選其中一項(xiàng)打，必填）：口符合博士學(xué)位論文要求，準(zhǔn)予預(yù)答辯；（80分以上）口基本符合博士學(xué)位論文要求，但需要對(duì)論文進(jìn)行修改后預(yù)答辯；（70分以上）口基本符合博士學(xué)位論文要求，對(duì)論文修改后重評(píng)；（60分-69分）口不符合博士學(xué)位論文要求，不準(zhǔn)予預(yù)答辯；（60分以下）評(píng)閱人姓名（可匿名）評(píng)閱人職稱評(píng)閱人研究方向是否博士生導(dǎo)師評(píng)閱專家對(duì)論文內(nèi)容的熟悉程度非常熟悉（）比較熟悉（）()/、熟悉（）.，"Cun”FunmiL-.“'.of”"r-aelisLILilye-lmic.nti*fillimpl.".<一.“，“aILprvi.,andmuni.,.1.unic.00.pr.pay.l.、re.，rl*.1”.,.r.”.I”."nannl.-"一"“""-'_|IaIL.kill.mnnor”.1.”ulLept,.n.”*all-nas,.“edta0".”,eunmic”tn&quo